This clown car is missing its clowns….

PAKFA Damage \

Photo courtesy of Sukhoi


Above is a photo of a recent mishap that took place aboard one of the five T-50 prototypes. According to an account found online, the above seen T-50 took to the air and shortly after takeoff communications with ATC (Air Traffic Control) was lost. Shortly after loss of comms, an engine chip alarm (metal shavings detected) sounded, forcing the pilot to shut down the starboard side engine. Soon after, the pilot landed the aircraft, and taxied to the shutdown point on the tarmac. Once at a stop, the pilot took notice of “intense black smoke pouring from the port engine”. Jumping from the aircraft, the pilot saw a puddle of burning fuel beneath the aircraft and sprinted away.

The T-50 is a young program, and these things are known to happen. What I find amusing is the deafening silence from Sukhoi fanboys and F-35 critics alike. One of my favorite anti-JSF mouth breathers responded by saying the T-50 proved it can successfully land on one engine. As this specific individual weights his every comment as an F-35 barb, the spirit of his comment is clear. To that I find myself laughing until my sides hurt. Mouth breather, we’ll call you Eric, or the drive by blogger if you like, the F-35 demonstrates the ability to land with a single operational engine each and every time it flies due in large part to the fact that the F-35 is a single engine aircraft. Obvious, I know.


Often, F-35 critics use the T-50 as a tool to proclaim doom, gloom, and the impending failure of the JSF program. Isn’t it odd that those who lionize the T-50 are silent on this event, or dismissive at best? I think so. Consider what these same individuals would have said if this event had befallen an F-35 for a moment. The gnashing of teeth and beating of breasts would have taken place high and low across the web. Several individuals whom Sukhoi fanboyism runs strong within have issued proclamations that the above test aircraft will be repaired soon, and nothing to worry about exists because Sukhoi has said as such. Keep in mind that these are the same individuals who claim everything uttered by Lockheed Martin is nothing more than propaganda at best, and a lie at worst. Why the double standard my dear mouth breathers? Is this clown car missing its clowns? Perhaps Aviation Week’s Bill Sweetman hasn’t yet circulated talking points to his merry band of clowns……one wonders.

Had a single event of this magnitude taken place aboard an F-35 critics would have proclaimed blood is in the water. Consider for a second that the above shown T-50 represents 20% of the total T-50 fleet in existence. Not only has an event of this magnitude never taken place aboard an F-35, not a single test article has been lost. Imagine the outrage if twenty percent of the F-35 fleet had just been rendered unusable. From the photo above it is abundantly clear that this was a Class A mishap. Personally, I wouldn’t put great odds on this T-50 ever flying again.

The single most interesting portion of the event was not the event itself, but who was present to witness the whole show. This test flight was more of a demonstration flight meant to woo an Indian delegation. The Indian/Russian relationship as it relates to the T-50 has been a somewhat strained one this last year, and I’m sure this didn’t help much at all. Anyone who believes this event, witnessed by an Indian delegation, will not alter India’s thinking on the T-50 is absolutely delusional. Add this unfortunate event to the already present concerns India harbors on work share, technology transfer, etc, and you have a recipe to bake a wonderful cake that will be purchased from a nation other than Russia.

If India bails on the T-50, you have a program that is suddenly teetering on the edge. Abandoning the program would mean Indian developmental funds would also vanish. Remove the one hundred plus airframes the Indian’s intend to purchase, and you have a massive increase in per aircraft purchase price for Russia, who at this time only plan on around two hundred airframes. Combine this with a Russian economy that is in serious trouble and you have an unaffordable program. JSF critics love to chant ‘death spiral’. Funny, no such death spiral has gripped the F-35 yet it may sink the T-50.  Recent forward movement to finalize India’s Rafale deal opens the possibility that a portion of funds India intends to pour into T-50 may end up instead being used for further Rafale orders. Time will tell.

In closing, it is my sincere hope that those suffering from Sukhoi fanboyism and those who carry a rabid and unhealthy hate for the F-35 hop back in their clown car. Look where it has taken them so far!


~ by arcturus415 on June 13, 2014.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: